Friday, November 2, 2012

Preparing For Disaster - Site Selection


Hurricane Sandy brings many DR concerns back to the forefront. I've spoken to clients that utilize both East and West coast datacenters to ask about their methodology when choosing each location to mitigate the possibility of outages due to disaster. A series of questions emerged for the initial site selection process:

1) Minimum 1 mile from interstate.
2) Minimum ½ mile from major rail. Commuter rail is less of concern.
3) Not in flight paths AND two miles from major airports and one mile from regional airports.
4) Minimum 500 year flood plain.
5) Note location and capacity of levy or aqueduct system.
6) Surrounding Properties or other tenants may not handle or store any hazardous material, such as gas stations, propane refilling stations, hazardous material storage.
7) Minimum 50 miles from nuclear power plants.
8) Not adjacent to water or communication towers.
9) Minimum ½ mile from major fuel pipelines.
10) Minimum ½ mile from grain elevators.
11) Proximity to fault lines.
12) Emergency Services – (fire, police, and ambulance).

The obvious question is where does one get answers? Let's step through one at a time with the reason for the question and places to get answers.

1) Interstate proximity - The interstate itself obviously doesn't pose a problem as roadways usually do not experience spontaneous combustion. The real danger is in overland freight, namely fuel and dangerous chemicals. The odd thing about this requirement is that you really want a major interstate or freeway close enough to the location so you know there is an ample transportation artery in case you need to get the facility in a hurry, but you don't want it so close to where an explosion or chemical hazard can cause a problem. The Internet mapping sites (Bing Maps, Google Maps, MapQuest, Yahoo! Maps) will show location and a scale, but do not measure distance. This is probably acceptable for most applications with just a screen shot for proof, but if you want more accuracy, use Google Earth. You can plot the colo address and then use the ruler tool to show much more accurate distance "as the crow flies", rather than driving distance which is less accurate.

2) Rail proximity - Major rail means freight rail and has the same concerns as overland freight. In addition, trains tend to weigh a whole lot more than cars, so the idea of a facility with an adjacent track is not too appealing in case of derailment. Again, the easiest methods to find rail information will be to use an Internet map to locate the rail and then Google Earth to verify proximity. But wait, there are many other ways that are more accurate. BNSF and CSX are two of the major rail companies in the US. There are many sites that will give you "system" maps with a general overview, but for specific information, you can contact the company real estate department and obtain detailed maps. If you are not sure of the rail company that operates the rail lines close to you, you can always get track ID or crossing information at most railroad crossings and give those numbers to the rail operator to verify you receive the correct maps.

3) Flight paths - Avoiding the major airline flights paths is for obvious reasons. While such disasters are extremely uncommon, the size, weight, and speed of the plane is only compounded by the avaiation fuel aboard. I'm fortunate to have many pilot friends that are happy to share information. Two excellent resources are VFRMAP and FlightAware. An example for the city of Austin would be to check VFRMAP: (http://vfrmap.com/?type=vfrc&lat=30.195&lon=-97.670&zoom=10), noticing the light blue line with "V xxx" that shows typical airplane routing, then verifying the routes against previously recording flights in FlightAware (http://flightaware.com/live/airport/KAUS). The first few times are duanting with the level of information on each map, but you will get the hang of it. Just a note, the main page of VFRMAP is actually the map. Zoom out on the upper left corner and move the map to your region, then zoom in to the airports. Another pilot friend points out that approach and takeoff procedures for all airports are available via AirNav (http://www.airnav.com/). This will show the acceptable routes in and out. He also brings up an interesting statement in that airplanes do not crash on the actual flight path, they crash on deviations to the flight path. In his humble opinion, the safest place to be is in the actual direct flight path. Food for thought?

4) Flood plain - Electricity and water do not mix well. Whether you believe the flood plain number should be 100 year, 200 year, or 500 year, the research is the same. FEMA provides flood plain maps available for download on the main site. Each map is inexpensive, at usually just a few dollars. Search for your state, then county, then community. You can view each map ahead of time to verify you are purchasing the correct location. The URL for the FEMA flood maps is https://msc.fema.gov/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/CategoryDisplay?catalogId=10001&storeId=10001&categoryId=12001&langId=-1&userType=G&type=1&future=false

5) Levy system - Electricity and water still do not mix well. Levy and aqueduct infrastructure is sometimes locally supported and sometimes state supported. You can note the location and distance of each system using the same methods as the interstate or rail lines above. Regarding any city plans for reinforcement, etc., your best bet is to search the city websites for "flood" information. Some cities, such as Santa Clara, CA, provide quite a bit of information directly on their site. With other cities you may need to call the city offices to obtain any project information.

6) Hazardous storage - Most Internet mapping systems will allow you to zoom down to street level and will give you the business entity name at surrounding properties. The easiest thing to do is print out a few maps, then drive around and see for yourself what is close to your property. The concerns with hazardous material storage are obvious, and, as most facilities are in industrial parks, businesses such as gas stations are not as much of an issue.

7) Nuclear power - Thankfully, US nuclear power plants are built to an amazing structural integrity level. Whether you believe in the likelihood of a power plant threat, either natural or man made, is not the issue. We are discussing risk mitigation, which means we might as well add large scale hydro as well as coal facilities to this concern. Internet search is your friend. Wikipedia gives you a nice list of power plants (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_reactors) that you can plot, then using Google Earth, measure the distance to your facility as the crow flies. Do the same for dams and reservoirs (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_dams_and_reservoirs_in_the_United_States), coal power stations (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_coal_power_stations) and any other power generation that may be of interest.

8) Communication towers - Companies like American Tower own a massive amount of the communication towers in the US. Luckily, they make their tower locations available to the public (http://www.americantower.com/sitelocator/default.aspx). Unfortunately, they are not the only provider. It appears that most customers are not worried about a small rooftop cell site nearly as much as a major tower. You can spot most major towers in rural areas using Internet mapping, but in business or CBD areas, it is more difficult as they are usually not stand alone. For this purpose, I usually rely on detective work or assessing the datacenter area for several blocks in all directions, then crossing that information with Internet search and tower search. It is not foolproof  but will get you in the ballpark. Water towers are up high. Look for them on tops of hills or free standing on huge legs. Either can be seen in aerial maps.

9) Pipelines - Gas pipelines usually refers to natural gas. Again, the Internet is your friend (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_natural_gas_pipelines). Pipeline maps are also available from most local power providers, such as this zoomable map from PG&E (http://www.pge.com/pipelineplanning/). If you cannot find a local provider pipeline map, just call into their HQ and request one. Most likely it is already available, but the nice person there can direct you. Gasoline pipelines are often only located within the refinery property. The next step would be to identify refineries in your area. Again, thank you Internet (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_oil_refineries). Verify property relative size and location using Internet mapping and Google Earth.

10) Grain elevators? Seriously? Yes, to many in the Midwest and east coast, this is truly a risk. I'd never seen one explode, but after viewing a few videos, I understand the risk. First of all, if you are in an industrial park in a major city, there is almost no chance of a close grain elevator. If your facility is rural, then you need to do some checking. Again, the Internet gives us a start (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_grain_elevators), but seems very incomplete. When asked for this info, I cross a few Internet searches with the good old phone book to look up grain companies. Most purchased grain and distributed it, but I was able to ask each where the major grain elevators were located in their area. Not 100% complete, but with enough phone calls and overlapping source information for an area, it was good enough in the eyes of each client.

11) Fault lines and earthquakes - There is a great faultline at Lawrence and 101, but that is the Faultline Brewery and probably not what the customer is asking. Here, in earthquake country, there are several fault lines that are active from time to time. There are many others in the US, but CA seems to have the stigma due to proximity to the tectonic plates. The USGS provides fault and earthquake maps for all regions. Just go to USGS (http://www.usgs.gov/) and search for fault line or earthquake and you can see the regional and national results along with maps.

12) Emergency services - Look up emergency services in your local phone book. Additionally, each state should list red cross and other shelter location for each of their counties, such as this map of shelters for the State of Florida (http://floridadisaster.org/shelters/).

Good luck in assembling your quick list of answers. Contact me if you require help as I am happy to consult to deliver a risk mitigation info packet for your location.

1 comment:

  1. Nice list! The additional item I'd throw in is Mother Nature. Nothing like selecting a DR site to Hurricane-proof your East Coast installation, only to find out, while it scores high on meeting the above criteria, it's on a side street of Tornado Alley!

    ReplyDelete