Thursday, November 15, 2012

Wholesale Is Not Retail - Part 2

In Part 1 of this thread we discussed the general differences of Wholesale and Retail and how the lines have been blurred by the providers and customer expectations. In this second part we will discuss the main business ramifications of selling metered power in a retail environment.

The general components of a wholesale deal are comprised of space, power, and cooling. Some providers will separate space to multiple components including the physical computing environment as well as CAM, or Common Area Maintenance charges. For our discussion, we will limit this to the former, but as a buyer, just add these charges together if you are comparing service offerings. Floor space is represented as per Kilowatt charges. This is counter intuitive to many as Kilowatt is an electrical term, but is used to price the floor space or rent component. The reason for this is very simple. Metered power is a pass through charge to the customer and NOT a profit center for the provider. The provider will use the committed amount of power to first determine the size of the footprint, as per our discussion of watts-per-square-foot, and will then use the committed power with their own pricing structure and market rates to determine if the deal is profitable. Remember, you are really only selling space, as a landlord, at this point. Power is paid through you to the electrical company. The third component, cooling, is represented as a PUE charge. PUE is an ever changing number from the point of commissioning of a building and fluctuates based on fill rate, temperatures, etc. In terms of contract negotiation, it is usually a fixed number that describes the price a customer will pay for cooling of the power consumed. If the PUE is 1.5 for the wholesale location, the customer will pay the electrical bill and .5 times the electrical bill for cooling of the electrical. The major debate is whether PUE and cooling charges can be considered a profit center to the provider. Remember, the customer is paying for actual power consumed and therefore the PUE charge is a real cost the provider, which means there is little to no margin and may actually be a loss if the contracted PUE is lower than the actual PUE of the facility.

We can clearly see of the three charges to the customer - floor space, power, and cooling - that floor space is the only charge that carries any potential for margin. There are other variables that will affect cost to the provider and price to the customer, such as the point where power is measured, as well as "break points" of how much power can be offered before the provider must spend to build additional infrastructure, but I think you can clearly see that in wholesale, you are a landlord that is really selling space only. This explains the lean staffing and massive footprints of many wholesale providers.

Let's juxtapose this to a retail environment. In a retail environment  the request for metered power is becoming more prevalent. Minimum power commitments are going as low as 150kW to switch "per breaker" pricing to metered power pricing. Let's look at pricing in such a scenario:

Retail customer XYZ Corp has agreed to 150kW of power in a retail environment, consisting of 30 pairs of 208v-30A circuits, totally 149,760 watts of power. Let's do the math in the old model of per circuit pricing and per square foot floor space pricing. Assuming per circuit pricing is $650 per primary circuit and $300 per redundant circuit, this equates to (30 * $650) + (30 * $300) = $28,500. If floor space is $20/sq ft with a facility power density of 150w/sq ft, this equates to 149,760 / 150 = 998.4, which we will round up to 1,000 sq ft @ $20/sq ft = $20,000. This deal is therefore worth $48,500. Now, a retail environment that only uses a price per kW charge all inclusive @ $300 would equate to 150kW x $300 = $45,000. There is a caveat. *Most* of the time, a savvy buyer will just compare total price, regardless of how you calculate it, so if provider B is quoting $45,000, provider A @ $48,500 obviously needs to explain the pricing delta with a proposed superior offering. In either scenario, the sales rep will most likely be paid on the total deal value, whether it is $48,500 or $45,000. In a wholesale model for the same 150kW, the price may be $150 per kW for the floor space, or $22,500. The power is a pass-through to the client, but let's assume 150 kW @ 12.5 cents/kWh for the 730.484 hours in a month, or (150 * $0.125 * 730.484) = $13,695.64. The PUE cooling charge, assuming full power draw against commit, with a 1.5 PUE facility would be 1.5 * $13,695.6375 = $20,543.46 for a total deal value of $22,500. Wait, you say the math doesn't add up? Remember, the only thing pre-billed each month is the space of $22,500. Power and cooling are post-billed after usage and most likely you will not be paid on either.

So, let's do some simple math. Commission on $48,500 is better than commission on $22,500. Now you see what offering metered power in a retail environment will do to your margins and your commissions.

No comments:

Post a Comment