We've Moved. Go to http://coloadvisors.com for our blog.
Friday, December 7, 2012
We've Moved
We are now at our permanent home at http://coloadvisors.com/blog - come see our latest posts and what ColoAdvisors can do for your company.
Monday, November 26, 2012
Anatomy of a Cloud
Cloud certainly has become a catch-all phrase, seemingly describing everything from seemingly ubiquitous storage to computing on demand. "Put it in the cloud". I knew it was part of our vocabulary when my mother-in-law said it. In our business of selling services as well as the customers business of purchasing services, we need to understand what "the cloud" can offer, and more importantly, how it stacks up against traditional colocation and network services.
Let's start with some basic terms for the cloud - Public, Private, Hybrid. Public cloud is a service that is open to Internet where a service provider controls the infrastructure, yet the customer controls the provisioning of services. Private, or Enterprise cloud is a dedicated infrastructure for a single client. This still can be, and many times is, open to the Internet, but is a single customer solution. Hybrid describes a scenario where some customer infrastructure interfaces with either a public or private cloud solution, such as when a customer owns the web servers, but the provider owns the network and storage. This scenario generally happens when a customer already has colocation, but wants or needs to retain part of the infrastructure control. Many times Public cloud is described as a scenario where there is no monthly commit, whereas a Private and Hybrid solution has a longer term contract and commit. There is another term to learn when discussing cloud and that is virtualization. Think of virtualization as the ability to transform a computing system or environment, that was run on physical equipment, to a logical or software version of that same equipment or environment. Virtualization is still run on servers, but the servers may be provided by a service provider. Virtualization is a component of the cloud, but is not the cloud itself. We'll discuss this important distinction further on.
The cloud DOES live somewhere. Where does it live? It lives in datacenters and colocation facilities. This is confusing to many people as it sounds like the cloud does not remove you from the physical datacenter environment. Truth be known, this is exactly the case. A cloud provider has network, server, and storage components (and many others) that still reside in a datacenter or colocation. What a service provider is offering a customer is the ability to purchase and provision on demand, purchase in most any quantity, pay for what you use, provide hardware and software refreshes and updates, and provide any break-fix to the physical infrastructure. The exact details will depend on the type of cloud and the provider. The cloud DOES NOT alleviate the datacenter for the provider, but the goal is that it alleviates any burden of datacenter or colocation management from the customer. Amazon servers live in a datacenter. Rackspace servers live in a datacenter. QTS servers live in a datacenter. Hopefully they all live in multiple datacenters, but that will be another blog post. Do not sell or buy the cloud as a move away from the datacenter, but instead as value of not having to manage the infrastructure.
Cloud architectures are inherently redundant, when built correctly. The question becomes whether this redundancy extends beyond one datacenter location. Within a single datacenter a cloud provider will have multiple networks, multiple network equipment with automatic fail-over, multiple servers, redundancy within the servers, and a redundant form of storage. But what happens if the facility has an outage? That is the golden question, which leads us back to Disaster Recovery and Business Continuity, as we have previously discussed and will discuss specific to the cloud in a future blog post.
Let's get back to virtualization. Some providers offer what they call virtualization services, whether branded as cloud or not. Cloud by its nature allows the virtualization of network, systems, and storage. What you need to verify is whether the virtualization or cloud services have self provisioning. Many times, a provider will virtualize and existing computing environment and arrange for transfer of the virtual machines, but may not offer customers the ability to further provision on their own. As a seller, verify what your company offers. As a buyer, find out if self provisioning is a necessity.
These are just the basics. In the next post, we will speak more in-depth about maximizing the cloud.
Tuesday, November 20, 2012
Genesis of a Partner Ecosystem
It amazes me how much money is left on the table. When you think of a client's needs, they really extend very, very far beyond most company's services. Every customer has an intricate infrastructure consisting of IT functions in addition to web functions. IT functions can include voice services, office networks, desktop support, desktop virtualization, VPN/firwall services, and a host of other things not normally offered by colo providers. So why do you care? Simple, you want to make money.
A healthy partner ecosystem takes time and effort to develop Having a pair of vendors for each potential customer requirement is a great place to start. Our modus operandi has been to start with what you know (and who you know). If you have a contact at another vendor that is reliable, start there. Grab your trusty Excel program and map out the services that vendor can provide. Not sure what you customer needs? Take a look at your own company needs for a start. You'll find your customer has similar infrastructure requirements. A good starting list may be:
Hardware
Network hardware - routers, switches, firewalls, load balancers
Server hardware
Desktop hardware
Office phones and switches
Network
Office to office (including partners)
Office to colo
Office to Internet
Colo to Internet
Managed Services
Managed Backup (or Backup-As-A-Services)
Managed Storage (or Storage-As-A-Services)
Managed network and equipment
Remote hands
Operations and IT support staff
Virtualization
Server virtualization
Desktop virtualization
Voice
That list is 2 minutes off the top of my head. There are many other areas where you can find needs. How many questions do you ask your customer about their business and technical needs beyond what you directly offer? If you are already pitching the customer for your own business solution, why not take a few minutes and discuss other areas where they may have needs or can make introductions? The money is there. The question is whether you will get it or someone else.
If your company does not currently have a partner ecosystem, you can still create one yourself. Just make sure you are not violating any company policy by receiving fees from the partners. If your company does have a partner ecosystem, it would behoove you to find out who is a partner and what they can provide rather than just waiting for them to funnel you leads. Need more convincing? This year a friend that is not in sales has already added over $110K to his salary just by pushing hardware and network (non-competing products for his company) to clients - all because he asked a few questions and knew where to direct the customer for answers.
Thursday, November 15, 2012
Wholesale Is Not Retail - Part 2
In Part 1 of this thread we discussed the general differences of Wholesale and Retail and how the lines have been blurred by the providers and customer expectations. In this second part we will discuss the main business ramifications of selling metered power in a retail environment.
The general components of a wholesale deal are comprised of space, power, and cooling. Some providers will separate space to multiple components including the physical computing environment as well as CAM, or Common Area Maintenance charges. For our discussion, we will limit this to the former, but as a buyer, just add these charges together if you are comparing service offerings. Floor space is represented as per Kilowatt charges. This is counter intuitive to many as Kilowatt is an electrical term, but is used to price the floor space or rent component. The reason for this is very simple. Metered power is a pass through charge to the customer and NOT a profit center for the provider. The provider will use the committed amount of power to first determine the size of the footprint, as per our discussion of watts-per-square-foot, and will then use the committed power with their own pricing structure and market rates to determine if the deal is profitable. Remember, you are really only selling space, as a landlord, at this point. Power is paid through you to the electrical company. The third component, cooling, is represented as a PUE charge. PUE is an ever changing number from the point of commissioning of a building and fluctuates based on fill rate, temperatures, etc. In terms of contract negotiation, it is usually a fixed number that describes the price a customer will pay for cooling of the power consumed. If the PUE is 1.5 for the wholesale location, the customer will pay the electrical bill and .5 times the electrical bill for cooling of the electrical. The major debate is whether PUE and cooling charges can be considered a profit center to the provider. Remember, the customer is paying for actual power consumed and therefore the PUE charge is a real cost the provider, which means there is little to no margin and may actually be a loss if the contracted PUE is lower than the actual PUE of the facility.
We can clearly see of the three charges to the customer - floor space, power, and cooling - that floor space is the only charge that carries any potential for margin. There are other variables that will affect cost to the provider and price to the customer, such as the point where power is measured, as well as "break points" of how much power can be offered before the provider must spend to build additional infrastructure, but I think you can clearly see that in wholesale, you are a landlord that is really selling space only. This explains the lean staffing and massive footprints of many wholesale providers.
Let's juxtapose this to a retail environment. In a retail environment the request for metered power is becoming more prevalent. Minimum power commitments are going as low as 150kW to switch "per breaker" pricing to metered power pricing. Let's look at pricing in such a scenario:
Retail customer XYZ Corp has agreed to 150kW of power in a retail environment, consisting of 30 pairs of 208v-30A circuits, totally 149,760 watts of power. Let's do the math in the old model of per circuit pricing and per square foot floor space pricing. Assuming per circuit pricing is $650 per primary circuit and $300 per redundant circuit, this equates to (30 * $650) + (30 * $300) = $28,500. If floor space is $20/sq ft with a facility power density of 150w/sq ft, this equates to 149,760 / 150 = 998.4, which we will round up to 1,000 sq ft @ $20/sq ft = $20,000. This deal is therefore worth $48,500. Now, a retail environment that only uses a price per kW charge all inclusive @ $300 would equate to 150kW x $300 = $45,000. There is a caveat. *Most* of the time, a savvy buyer will just compare total price, regardless of how you calculate it, so if provider B is quoting $45,000, provider A @ $48,500 obviously needs to explain the pricing delta with a proposed superior offering. In either scenario, the sales rep will most likely be paid on the total deal value, whether it is $48,500 or $45,000. In a wholesale model for the same 150kW, the price may be $150 per kW for the floor space, or $22,500. The power is a pass-through to the client, but let's assume 150 kW @ 12.5 cents/kWh for the 730.484 hours in a month, or (150 * $0.125 * 730.484) = $13,695.64. The PUE cooling charge, assuming full power draw against commit, with a 1.5 PUE facility would be 1.5 * $13,695.6375 = $20,543.46 for a total deal value of $22,500. Wait, you say the math doesn't add up? Remember, the only thing pre-billed each month is the space of $22,500. Power and cooling are post-billed after usage and most likely you will not be paid on either.
So, let's do some simple math. Commission on $48,500 is better than commission on $22,500. Now you see what offering metered power in a retail environment will do to your margins and your commissions.
The general components of a wholesale deal are comprised of space, power, and cooling. Some providers will separate space to multiple components including the physical computing environment as well as CAM, or Common Area Maintenance charges. For our discussion, we will limit this to the former, but as a buyer, just add these charges together if you are comparing service offerings. Floor space is represented as per Kilowatt charges. This is counter intuitive to many as Kilowatt is an electrical term, but is used to price the floor space or rent component. The reason for this is very simple. Metered power is a pass through charge to the customer and NOT a profit center for the provider. The provider will use the committed amount of power to first determine the size of the footprint, as per our discussion of watts-per-square-foot, and will then use the committed power with their own pricing structure and market rates to determine if the deal is profitable. Remember, you are really only selling space, as a landlord, at this point. Power is paid through you to the electrical company. The third component, cooling, is represented as a PUE charge. PUE is an ever changing number from the point of commissioning of a building and fluctuates based on fill rate, temperatures, etc. In terms of contract negotiation, it is usually a fixed number that describes the price a customer will pay for cooling of the power consumed. If the PUE is 1.5 for the wholesale location, the customer will pay the electrical bill and .5 times the electrical bill for cooling of the electrical. The major debate is whether PUE and cooling charges can be considered a profit center to the provider. Remember, the customer is paying for actual power consumed and therefore the PUE charge is a real cost the provider, which means there is little to no margin and may actually be a loss if the contracted PUE is lower than the actual PUE of the facility.
We can clearly see of the three charges to the customer - floor space, power, and cooling - that floor space is the only charge that carries any potential for margin. There are other variables that will affect cost to the provider and price to the customer, such as the point where power is measured, as well as "break points" of how much power can be offered before the provider must spend to build additional infrastructure, but I think you can clearly see that in wholesale, you are a landlord that is really selling space only. This explains the lean staffing and massive footprints of many wholesale providers.
Let's juxtapose this to a retail environment. In a retail environment the request for metered power is becoming more prevalent. Minimum power commitments are going as low as 150kW to switch "per breaker" pricing to metered power pricing. Let's look at pricing in such a scenario:
Retail customer XYZ Corp has agreed to 150kW of power in a retail environment, consisting of 30 pairs of 208v-30A circuits, totally 149,760 watts of power. Let's do the math in the old model of per circuit pricing and per square foot floor space pricing. Assuming per circuit pricing is $650 per primary circuit and $300 per redundant circuit, this equates to (30 * $650) + (30 * $300) = $28,500. If floor space is $20/sq ft with a facility power density of 150w/sq ft, this equates to 149,760 / 150 = 998.4, which we will round up to 1,000 sq ft @ $20/sq ft = $20,000. This deal is therefore worth $48,500. Now, a retail environment that only uses a price per kW charge all inclusive @ $300 would equate to 150kW x $300 = $45,000. There is a caveat. *Most* of the time, a savvy buyer will just compare total price, regardless of how you calculate it, so if provider B is quoting $45,000, provider A @ $48,500 obviously needs to explain the pricing delta with a proposed superior offering. In either scenario, the sales rep will most likely be paid on the total deal value, whether it is $48,500 or $45,000. In a wholesale model for the same 150kW, the price may be $150 per kW for the floor space, or $22,500. The power is a pass-through to the client, but let's assume 150 kW @ 12.5 cents/kWh for the 730.484 hours in a month, or (150 * $0.125 * 730.484) = $13,695.64. The PUE cooling charge, assuming full power draw against commit, with a 1.5 PUE facility would be 1.5 * $13,695.6375 = $20,543.46 for a total deal value of $22,500. Wait, you say the math doesn't add up? Remember, the only thing pre-billed each month is the space of $22,500. Power and cooling are post-billed after usage and most likely you will not be paid on either.
So, let's do some simple math. Commission on $48,500 is better than commission on $22,500. Now you see what offering metered power in a retail environment will do to your margins and your commissions.
Tuesday, November 13, 2012
Wholesale Is Not Retail
The terms wholesale and retail have been kicked around the datacenter industry for quite a while now. There used to be a very clear delineation of service, as well as type of customer purchasing the service. Wholesale was large swaths of space and a set amount of power, usually sized by the service demarcation point of the power distribution equipment, along with metered power and lease terms that resembled a real estate transaction. Retail was generally smaller space with set power circuit types, such as 120v-20A or 208v-30A designated by a circuit or whip delivered to a customer environment, as well as a more bundled approach to contracted services. What we have seen in the last few years is a blurring of the lines and a distinct lack of definition of product. Let's take a look at the general differences and why selling to an improperly categorized client can be bad for your company.
Historically, wholesale environments for any product were designed to allow a producer or distributor to sell in bulk to bulk purchasers that, in turn, would resell the services to consumers. This held true for most industries, whether it be groceries or automobiles, etc. The price of the goods was lower, as the bulk buying allowed more goods to be sold at a time, but in turn the level of service received was much lower as the bulk purchaser would be providing any services needed to the consumer. In our grocery analogy, this means the farmers or large scale producers would sell to grocery stores and the grocery store would provide all the services for the consumer, such as cleaning, preparing, staging, pricing of the goods as well as the end checkout, bagging, and other infrastructure. The combination of lower volume purchases by the consumer as well as services provided by the grocer allowed the grocer to add margin into their pricing. The grocer had created a retail offering from their wholesale purchases.
Our industry worked the same way. Datacenters were built by real estate companies (landlords) with large expanses of space and power leased to providers that in turn would de-aggregate the space, power, and cooling and would provide a lower volume product with additional services added to the consumer. And everyone was happy for a while. So what has changed? The biggest change is in the understanding. Nowadays, the wholesale and retail model has been modified as wholesale sellers have started offering retail services directly to the consumer, necessitating the retail supplier to offer wholesale services to compete, effectively adding market competition and squeezing margin, while in many cases not providing a high level of service. Consumers now think of wholesale as a pricing methodology without understanding the service component. Retail providers have been forced to offer wholesale attributes to retail clients, most notably in the form of metered power instead of per circuit pricing.
Why is this bad? Most wholesale datacenter providers have smaller staffs as they are geared toward fewer, but larger clients. For the wholesale datacenter provider, this may mean overworking the staff to accommodate requests normally handled by the retail providers, such as individual circuit installations, cage, cabinet, and suite installations, and fielding questions about services not traditionally offered by wholesale providers. For the consumer, this usually means a much lower support capability, longer lead times, fewer service choices, and a host of related issues. And what about for the retail provider. They are getting the worst of it - increased competition from dissimilar offerings that "look" similar as well as severely eroded margins.
The blurring of these lines will continue. In our next post we'll specifically discuss metered vs. circuit power and what some providers have done to protect erosion in this changing market.
Friday, November 9, 2012
Buyers Don't Purchase On Price
In a meeting with a colocation prospect, he made a point of telling me that "price is all that matters". He emphasized this several more times within the first 5 minutes of the conversation. After finding out his current colocation spend I confidently informed him one of our partners could cut his price by 50%. He was quite happy. I then told him we would stack his equipment in the parking lot behind their building and run an extension cord from a wall outlet the janitorial service normally used for their vacuum cleaner. His expression changed and the meeting almost ended. Slowly he told me he wanted the best price for a "comparable solution" to his current environment. This quickly led to a discussion about the real problems he was facing with his current provider, the challenges he faced in his own operation of the environment, and the concerns about how to handle growth. Once we moved price out of the way, we were able to find the real issues and address each, leading back to an honest deal.
Time and time again we are caught up in this frenzy that a customer buys on price and we sell on price. Do you buy your cars on price only? If so, I know of a 1988 Yugo GV for sale. Or what about your clothes? A 1977 sky blue leisure suit is pretty cheap these days. We do not buy "the cheapest" for the sake of it being "the cheapest" for most of our purchases, so why do we try to sell that way to a customer? The reasons are plentiful, but the one that I continually see is perceived lack of differentiation. If you truly believe your product is a commodity and there is no value proposition, then you need to better understand your company market positioning. "Niche to win" is a common saying among start-ups, but it also holds true for infrastructure. You can create many niche stories to better position your product to the customer. If you do not know your company niches, I strongly suggest spending time with your product and marketing teams. I've not seen a single colocation company where there is not a niche story that positions the product set specific to a market vertical. Even if your solution is identical between one market vertical and another, there is no reason you cannot determine the customer problems solved by your product and why it is right for both verticals.
I use food analogies a lot. Infrastructure is like Mexican food - 7 ingredients arranged 29 different ways. What is the difference between a taco and a tostada? Not much. Your product and customer vertical positioning can be the same - same ingredients arranged in a way specific to the market vertical. Need more? Start off with "Our product is perfect for the medical industry because of ..." and then try "our product is perfect for the banking industry because of ...". The reasons might be similar, but now you have two distinct stories for two verticals. Easy, right?
Wednesday, November 7, 2012
Disaster Recovery Fundamentals
Now that we have defined DR in our last post, let's look at some of the options for creating a DR plan for your business or your customer.
In a disaster situation, both the users AND the data need to be shifted from one computing environment to another. This effectively means there are two DR plans that need to be enacted simultaneously. If you are only providing colocation to the client, then your only role is really to keep the facility from having an outage in the first place. Even with that limited role, it is still very important to speak to your customers about their own DR plans. At a minimum, it shows the customer you care about their business. And perhaps, you can also provide them white label or partner services that are of value to you and your company, as well as your partner ecosystem. Where things get complicated is if your company provides *some* level of managed services, but may not be responsible for the entire computing environment, including network or application. In such scenarios, your company is now part of the customer Operations team and will need to know exactly which services to provide in a DR situation and in which order, as well the triggers that put them in motion and their own feedback loop to the client when their portion of the work is complete. Yes, you are in the middle of a potential panicked situation. The last scenario, and least likely, is that your company provide full Operations support for the customer and owns the entire computing environment, as well as DR plan. This is least likely as the customer almost always owns at least the application and potentially the users, if they are corporate users and not Internet users.
The first half of our solution involves shifting users from one computing environment to another. Shifting Internet users is trivial now thanks to geoloadbalancing technologies that have matured in the last 15 years. In simple terms, this means there are two potential computing environments for the Internet user. The geoloadbalancing system will determine if one environment is available and the other is not available. It will then send Internet users to the available environment. Of course, there are a lot of bells and whistles that will allow tuning based on geography, network latency, computing environment load, and many other factors if both environments are available, but again, that is more of a Business Continuity scenario. For DR, let's just think of it as a light switch where an environment is ON or OFF, with only one environment being ON at a time and Internet users directed to that ON environment. Managed Services and network companies should be selling this capability. The second user scenario involves corporate or VPN users. Remote corporate users many times use VPN clients as a way to connect to a computing environment, usually for access to corporate file servers or email. The good news is that a VPN client can easily accommodate connections to differing computing environments, many times with the ability to automatically try secondary connections if the primary connection fails. This is called "rollever" and just means if computing environment A is not reachable, the VPN client will automatically try to connect to computing environment B. From an infrastructure standpoint, this simply means both computing environment A and computing environment B must have the ability to allow the corporate user VPN connection and to authenticate it. Simple tasks for your IT department. The scenario of an office connecting to the computing environment is very much the same as the VPN user. The only difference is that instead of a VPN client for each user, the office will have one large VPN tunnel that serves all users. In the case computing environment A is not avialable, the router or other VPN device will automatically "rollover" to computing environment B. In reality, the VPN device is continuously trying to connect to both environments and will just use the one that is available.
And now the real work - shifting data from one environment to another. It would be so nice if real time synchronous replication worked perfectly and was cheap, but this is just not the case. The engineers can explain the problems with trying to synchronize data between multiple environments, but from a business perspective, this just means about twice the cost of operation to keep mirrored environments available - twice the hardware, twice the space, twice the power, and maybe if you are lucky, you only have to pay network at one location. Synchronous replication is also more of a Business Continuity plan, so again, let's keep this as DR and the light switch - ON and OFF. In reality, if computing environment B is a physical coloction, the customer will always have the servers on and ready and maybe just not have data replicated. In such a scenario, the DR strategy for the data will be to move it from one location to another. This is usually done with block level replication, meaning chunks of data are transferred. The problem comes with just how much data is to be transferred and how fast it needs to be there. Remember, if computing environment A is down completely, a customer may not have any access to that data. Then how do we do it? By continuously replicating the data to another location. This is known as Storage-As-A-Service or Backup-As-A-Service when using a 3rd party. This is just replication if a client is using their own infrastructure. The data continuously gets backed up, then in a DR situation, is transferred again to computing environment B from the data backup location. Again, this has to be architected based on the amount of data and the time a customer must have it replicated to have computing environment B available. This is your SLA.
Virtualization to the rescue. There are a number of cloud service providers that will allow virtual machines to remain dormant (OFF) and provide a guarantee of how long it will take to turn on each virtual machine. This would be computing environment B. A customer may be able to only pay for storage without colocation or machines and then pay for computing cycles when the virtual machines are powered ON. Think of it - 1,000 virtual machines turning on in less than a minute. We still have the issue of getting the data to the virtual machine, but the customer now can save a massive amount of money for that secondary computing environment. Does your company offer this service? If not, you really should be looking to partner as a cohesive DR plan presented to a client is going to be of more value.
While these are just the basics of DR, hopefully it will provide you with more of an understanding and way to speak with your customer, as well as ideas for partnering in your ecosystem.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)