Tuesday, November 13, 2012

Wholesale Is Not Retail


The terms wholesale and retail have been kicked around the datacenter industry for quite a while now. There used to be a very clear delineation of service, as well as type of customer purchasing the service. Wholesale was large swaths of space and a set amount of power, usually sized by the service demarcation point of the power distribution equipment, along with metered power and lease terms that resembled a real estate transaction. Retail was generally smaller space with set power circuit types, such as 120v-20A or 208v-30A designated by a circuit or whip delivered to a customer environment, as well as a more bundled approach to contracted services. What we have seen in the last few years is a blurring of the lines and a distinct lack of definition of product. Let's take a look at the general differences and why selling to an improperly categorized client can be bad for your company.

Historically, wholesale environments for any product were designed to allow a producer or distributor to sell in bulk to bulk purchasers that, in turn, would resell the services to consumers. This held true for most industries, whether it be groceries or automobiles, etc. The price of the goods was lower, as the bulk buying allowed more goods to be sold at a time, but in turn the level of service received was much lower as the bulk purchaser would be providing any services needed to the consumer. In our grocery analogy, this means the farmers or large scale producers would sell to grocery stores and the grocery store would provide all the services for the consumer, such as cleaning, preparing, staging, pricing of the goods as well as the end checkout, bagging, and other infrastructure. The combination of lower volume purchases by the consumer as well as services provided by the grocer allowed the grocer to add margin into their pricing. The grocer had created a retail offering from their wholesale purchases.

Our industry worked the same way. Datacenters were built by real estate companies (landlords) with large expanses of space and power leased to providers that in turn would de-aggregate the space, power, and cooling and would provide a lower volume product with additional services added to the consumer. And everyone was happy for a while. So what has changed? The biggest change is in the understanding. Nowadays, the wholesale and retail model has been modified as wholesale sellers have started offering retail services directly to the consumer, necessitating the retail supplier to offer wholesale services to compete, effectively adding market competition and squeezing margin, while in many cases not providing a high level of service. Consumers now think of wholesale as a pricing methodology without understanding the service component. Retail providers have been forced to offer wholesale attributes to retail clients, most notably in the form of metered power instead of per circuit pricing.

Why is this bad? Most wholesale datacenter providers have smaller staffs as they are geared toward fewer, but larger clients. For the wholesale datacenter provider, this may mean overworking the staff to accommodate requests normally handled by the retail providers, such as individual circuit installations, cage, cabinet, and suite installations, and fielding questions about services not traditionally offered by wholesale providers. For the consumer, this usually means a much lower support capability, longer lead times, fewer service choices, and a host of related issues. And what about for the retail provider. They are getting the worst of it - increased competition from dissimilar offerings that "look" similar as well as severely eroded margins.

The blurring of these lines will continue. In our next post we'll specifically discuss metered vs. circuit power and what some providers have done to protect erosion in this changing market.

No comments:

Post a Comment